Skip to the story
All stories

5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge Wilson

The 9‑8 decision held that the Constitution’s Quorum Clause requires physical presence, noting 226 of 427 votes on the $1.7 trillion spending bill were cast by proxy.

AI-assisted coverage comparison, editor-supervised · How this was made

Published Updated
5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge Wilson

What this story says

  • The 5th Circuit ruled 9‑8 that physical presence is required for a House quorum.
  • When the $1.7 trillion spending bill passed, 226 of 427 votes were cast by proxy.
  • The court upheld an injunction blocking DOJ and EEOC enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against Texas.

Who covered it

Left 14%(2)Centre 29%(4)Right 57%(8)

Percentages are shares of the 14 outlets carrying a published leaning rating. 3 of the 17 outlets we know ran this story carry no rating and are not counted in them. Coverage measured .

Trust

64/100

Craft

85/100

Hype

15/100

17 sources · methodology

Thin on the left so far

Only 2 of the 14 outlets with a published leaning rating that ran this story are rated left.

This story is still being watched, so it is a count and not yet a finding. Coverage keeps arriving for hours after an event, and a side that has published nothing this morning may publish by tonight. If it is still true when we stop checking, we will say so plainly.

The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued a narrow ruling that the Constitution’s Quorum Clause obliges members of the House of Representatives to be physically present before the chamber can conduct business. The majority opinion, written by Judge Cory Wilson, rejected the argument that proxy voting satisfied the quorum requirement.

During the COVID‑19 pandemic the House adopted proxy voting. When the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 was approved in December 2022, 226 of the 427 votes were submitted by proxy. The Senate later passed the measure and President Joe Biden signed it into law.

The court also affirmed an injunction that prevents the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the State of Texas. The decision does not overturn the spending package or block the law’s application to private employers or other states.

“'proxy presence' does not count”

— Judge Cory Wilson, majority opinion author

$1.7 trillion

Spending package value

Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023

Blindspot

No left‑rated or right‑rated outlets published this story, leaving the coverage gap unfilled by those parts of the political spectrum.

Still developing. We have re-checked which outlets are covering this 9 times, most recently on 21 Nov 2026, 19:30, and will add the sides that appear.

How each side covered it

Our own reading of the reporting listed below, written from the outlets’ articles rather than quoted from them. The reasoning is set out on our methodology page.

Left

2 rated outlets

  • The US House of Representatives unconstitutionally passed a spending bill in 2022 using proxy voting, an appeals court ruled. The Spokesman-Review reported the decision concerned a $1.7 trillion government funding bill passed under a pandemic-era rule. This rule allowed lawmakers to vote in person or by proxy.
  • The ruling upheld an injunction sought by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton blocking enforcement of a provision for pregnant workers. The Spokesman-Review noted the bill passed the House with 226 members voting by proxy. Judge Cory Wilson wrote the proxy rule violated the Constitution's quorum clause.
  • A dissenting opinion from Judge James Graves called the ruling "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid." NBC News reported the ruling only affects the pregnant workers provision. The Spokesman-Review stated the Department of Justice and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission were barred from enforcing this provision against Texas.

Centre

4 rated outlets

  • News Facts Network highlighted the constitutional breach, the proxy‑vote count, and the upheld injunction. The report quoted Judge Cory Wilson’s statement that “'proxy presence' does not count” and noted Judge James Graves’s dissent questioning the need for physical presence. It described the ruling as potentially prompting further legal challenges.

Right

8 rated outlets

  • The right‑rated digests all led on the Fifth Circuit’s 9‑8 decision that the House’s use of proxy voting breached the Constitution’s quorum requirement. Each digest notes that the court found counting absent members toward a quorum unconstitutional, and that the ruling overturns the practice used during the pandemic.
  • Several digests added that the ruling affected a $1.7 trillion spending bill passed in 2022 and linked the decision to a Texas‑specific exemption from a pregnant‑workers law. Others identified Nancy Pelosi’s pandemic proxy scheme as the programme under scrutiny, and one noted the House vote tally of 225‑201 with 226 proxy votes recorded.
  • None of the right‑rated digests mention the name of the judge who authored the opinion, nor do they provide statements from lawmakers or legal scholars. They also omit any discussion of the dissenting judges or the broader constitutional arguments beyond the quorum clause.

Questions about this coverage

How did the left and right cover 5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge…?
Of the 14 outlets on this story carrying a published leaning rating, 14% are rated left, 29% are rated centre, 57% are rated right. Those percentages are shares of the rated outlets, not of every outlet that ran it, which was 17. The sections above set out what each side emphasised, in its own terms.
Is 5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge… left or right?
Neither side dominates it. Of the 14 rated outlets on this story, 14% are rated left, 29% are rated centre, 57% are rated right, and no side holds the 70% this site would want before calling a field one-sided. A story is not left or right in any case; the outlets that carried it are what carry ratings.
Is the coverage of 5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge… biased?
5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge Wilson is one event reported by 17 outlets, and this page does not rate the story as biased or unbiased. What it publishes is the spread: which outlets ran it, where named rating organisations place each of them on the spectrum, and what each side chose to lead with. A leaning rating describes an outlet's record over time, not this article, and the two should not be run together.
Which side is not reporting 5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge…?
When we first saw this story, outlets rated left had barely covered it. Coverage accretes for hours after an event, so that is where to look rather than a verdict — the split above is the current count, and it is the one to read.
Which outlets covered 5th Circuit rules proxy voting violates Constitution, citing Judge…?
17 that we know of, every one of them listed further up this page with a link to its own report and to what we hold on the publisher. Nothing here is a summary of somebody else's summary: the outlets are named so the original reporting can be read.
What did the 5th Circuit decide about proxy voting?
The 5th Circuit ruled 9‑8 that the Constitution’s Quorum Clause requires members to be physically present, declaring that proxy voting does not satisfy the quorum requirement. This decision applies to the House’s procedural rules and may lead to further challenges.
How many votes were cast by proxy on the spending bill?
When the $1.7 trillion Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023 passed in December 2022, 226 of the 427 total votes were submitted by proxy, according to the court’s findings reported by News Facts Network.
What injunction did the court uphold?
The court upheld an injunction that blocks the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act against the State of Texas, while leaving the law’s application to private employers and other states untouched.
Did any left‑ or right‑leaning outlets cover the story?
No left‑rated or right‑rated outlets ran the story; only the centre‑rated News Facts Network provided full coverage, creating a blindspot in the broader media landscape.

Read it at the source

17 outlets, grouped by the leaning a published rating gives them. Every headline links to the original; an underlined outlet name opens our profile of that publisher.

Left

2

Centre

4

Right

8

Not rated

3

How did this read?

About the coverage, not about the story. We do not ask whether you agree with what happened — we have no honest use for that answer.

5th Circuit proxy voting ruling | MediaBias News